Who Pays After an Accident in a Borrowed Car in Virginia?

A borrowed car can make an accident claim more complicated because more than one insurance policy may come into play. The owner’s policy may provide coverage when the driver had permission, while the borrower’s policy or applicable uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage may also become relevant. Who ultimately pays depends on permission, fault, policy terms, and the available coverage.

Fishwick & Associates PLC represents people injured in car accidents throughout the Roanoke Valley and western Virginia. Roanoke car accident attorney John P. Fishwick Jr. assists clients with borrowed car claims involving questions about permission, fault, insurance coverage, and serious injuries. Our team also handles Virginia car accident claims throughout the Commonwealth.

This guide explains how permissive use coverage works under Virginia law, how fault is determined, what happens when a driver lacks permission, when an owner can be held accountable for negligent entrustment, and what options remain when damages exceed the available policies. Call Fishwick & Associates PLC at (540) 345-5890 to discuss your claim.

Who is Considered Liable After a Borrowed Car Accident in Virginia?

When someone borrows a car with the owner’s permission, Virginia Code Section 38.2-2204 requires the owner’s liability policy to cover the permissive driver as an insured. This coverage can provide the first layer of protection after a crash, while the borrower’s own policy can provide additional or excess coverage depending on the terms of both policies.

This requirement is often called the omnibus clause, and it allows a permissive borrower to qualify as an insured even when that person is not named on the owner’s policy. Permission can be express, such as when the owner directly allows someone to use the vehicle, or implied through a pattern of conduct. For example, implied permission can exist when a family member regularly uses the car with the owner’s knowledge and without objection.

If the available liability insurance does not fully cover the injuries and property damage caused by the crash, other sources of coverage can become relevant. The borrower can also face personal liability for damages that remain unpaid after the applicable insurance is exhausted.

Key Takeaway: Virginia Code Section 38.2-2204 extends the owner’s liability coverage to a driver using the vehicle with permission. The terms of the applicable policies determine how that coverage applies after a crash.

Does the Car Owner’s Insurance Pay First in Virginia?

In many borrowed-car claims, the owner’s policy provides the first layer of liability coverage, while the borrower’s personal auto policy can provide additional or excess coverage. The order depends on the terms of both policies, including provisions that address coverage from other insurers.

For example, suppose a driver borrows a car and causes a crash on Williamson Road resulting in $175,000 in covered damages. If the owner’s policy provides primary coverage with a $100,000 per person liability limit, it can cover damages up to that limit. The borrower’s policy can then cover part or all of the remaining damages if it provides excess coverage for the borrowed vehicle.

The terms of the borrower’s policy are important because coverage for non-owned vehicles is not the same under every policy. Some policies also restrict coverage for vehicles furnished for regular use, so a car borrowed occasionally can be treated differently from one the driver uses on a regular basis.

Coverage Layer Whose Policy or Assets When It Applies
Owner’s liability coverage Vehicle owner Covers qualifying permissive drivers, subject to the policy’s terms and limits
Borrower’s liability coverage Borrowing driver Provides non-owned auto or excess coverage when included under the borrower’s policy
Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage Applicable UM/UIM policy Applies when the requirements for UM/UIM coverage are met
Personal assets Borrowing driver or an owner liable for negligent entrustment Can become relevant when applicable insurance does not fully cover the damages

Key Takeaway: The owner’s policy can provide the first layer of coverage when the borrower has permission to drive the vehicle, but the order of coverage is not automatic. The terms of the owner’s and borrower’s policies determine how each policy responds.

How Is Fault Determined in a Borrowed Car Accident?

Fault in a borrowed-car accident depends primarily on the conduct of the drivers, not who owns the vehicle. Investigators and insurers can consider factors such as speed, right-of-way, traffic signals, following distance, roadway conditions, witness accounts, and physical evidence from the crash. A vehicle owner can face separate liability when the facts support a claim such as negligent entrustment.

Virginia follows the contributory negligence rule. If an injured person’s own negligence contributed to the crash and was a proximate cause of the injuries, that person can be barred from recovering damages. Unlike comparative fault states, Virginia does not reduce compensation based on each person’s percentage of fault.

Evidence is therefore important when determining how the collision occurred and who was responsible. A police crash report can help identify witnesses, insurance information, and the responding officer’s initial observations, but it cannot be used as evidence at a trial arising from the accident under Virginia Code Section 46.2-379. Witness testimony, photographs, vehicle data, and admissible medical evidence can instead help establish fault and damages.

Car Accident Attorney in Roanoke – Fishwick & Associates PLC

John P. Fishwick Jr., Esq.

John P. Fishwick Jr. is a Roanoke car accident attorney and founder of Fishwick & Associates PLC who represents people injured in crashes throughout Virginia. He earned his J.D. cum laude from Washington and Lee University School of Law, where he served as Note and Comment Editor of the Washington and Lee Law Review, after receiving his B.A. from Harvard University.

John has extensive litigation experience, having previously served as United States Attorney for the Western District of Virginia from 2015 to 2017. His professional background also includes service on the Virginia Trial Lawyers Association’s Board of Governors and Executive Committee, and he is admitted to practice before the Supreme Court of Virginia, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, and the United States Supreme Court.

What If the Driver Lacked the Owner’s Permission?

Permission is important when determining whether the owner’s liability policy covers someone driving a borrowed vehicle. Virginia Code Section 38.2-2204 extends coverage to drivers using a vehicle with the owner’s consent, so coverage can be disputed when the vehicle was taken without permission or used beyond the permission the owner provided.

Lack of permission can involve a stolen vehicle, a family member who takes the keys without asking, or a driver who receives permission for a limited purpose but uses the vehicle differently. For example, someone allowed to move a truck across a driveway could instead take it for a ride across the city. In these situations, courts and insurers can consider the scope of the owner’s permission, the relationship between the parties, and their history of vehicle use.

If the owner’s policy does not cover the driver, the injured person can still have other sources of recovery. The driver’s own auto insurance or applicable uninsured motorist coverage can provide coverage, and the driver can also face personal liability for damages caused by the crash.

Can the Owner Be Liable for Negligent Entrustment?

A vehicle owner can be held accountable under Virginia’s negligent entrustment doctrine for allowing someone known to be unfit to drive to use the vehicle. The claim focuses on the owner’s decision to provide the vehicle and what the owner knew about the driver’s ability to operate it safely.

In Denby v. Davis, the Supreme Court of Virginia recognized that negligent entrustment can arise when an owner knew or had reasonable cause to know that the driver was unfit and likely to use the vehicle in a way that created an unreasonable risk of injury to others. The court’s decision in Turner v. Lotts also emphasizes the importance of evidence showing that the owner knew or had reason to know of the driver’s unfitness. The plaintiff must also establish that the negligent entrustment was a proximate cause of the injury.

Evidence of unfitness can include impairment, a physical condition that affects safe driving, lack of driving ability or experience, or a driving history that demonstrates the person was unsafe behind the wheel. However, an invalid license, prior crashes, or traffic violations do not automatically establish negligent entrustment. The circumstances must show that the owner knew or had reason to know the driver posed an unreasonable risk.

Key Takeaway: An owner who lends a vehicle to someone known to be unfit to drive can be held accountable for resulting damages under Virginia’s negligent entrustment doctrine. The claim depends on what the owner knew or had reason to know when the vehicle was entrusted to the driver.

What Happens If Damages Exceed Both Policies in Virginia?

When the available liability insurance does not fully cover the damages from a crash, underinsured motorist coverage can provide another source of recovery. If more than one UM/UIM policy applies, Virginia Code Section 38.2-2206 sets the order in which the policies respond. The policy covering the vehicle occupied by the injured person has first priority, followed by applicable policies covering vehicles not involved in the crash.

For qualifying new or renewed policies effective on or after July 1, 2023, Virginia requires UIM benefits to be paid without reducing them by liability coverage available for payment unless a named insured makes the statutory election allowing that reduction. This can affect the amount of coverage available when damages exceed the at-fault driver’s liability limits.

Virginia’s minimum liability limits have also increased. Under Virginia Code Section 46.2-472, policies effective on or after January 1, 2025 carry minimum limits of $50,000 per person and $100,000 per accident for bodily injury, along with $25,000 for property damage.

Insurance is not always the only potential source of recovery. A judgment can also be entered against the at-fault driver personally or against a vehicle owner found liable for negligent entrustment, although recovery depends on the assets available.

Key Takeaway: When available liability coverage is insufficient, applicable UIM coverage can provide additional recovery. If multiple UM/UIM policies apply, Virginia Code Section 38.2-2206 determines their order of priority.

Areas We Serve Near Roanoke, Virginia

Fishwick & Associates PLC represents injured people throughout Roanoke and the surrounding region, including Roanoke County, Botetourt County, Franklin County, Craig County, Montgomery County, Bedford County, Rockbridge County, and Floyd County. We also serve clients in Salem, Vinton, Cave Spring, Hollins, Blacksburg, Christiansburg, and Radford.

Our team handles car accident claims arising on major routes such as Interstate 81, Interstate 581, Route 220, and Route 460. In Roanoke, these cases can also involve busy local roads such as Franklin Road, Orange Avenue, Hershberger Road, and Peters Creek Road.

A borrowed car accident can involve questions about permission, fault, and which insurance policy applies. When more than one carrier is involved, determining the available coverage and how the policies respond is an important part of pursuing compensation.

John P. Fishwick Jr. represents people injured in car accidents throughout Roanoke and western Virginia. He works with clients to investigate the crash, address disputed liability and coverage issues, and pursue compensation from the responsible parties and applicable insurers.

Call Fishwick & Associates PLC at (540) 345-5890 for a free consultation. Our office at 30 Franklin Rd SW, Suite 700 in downtown Roanoke serves clients across the Roanoke Valley and western Virginia.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do you need your own insurance to drive someone else’s car in Virginia?

Not necessarily. An occasional permissive borrower does not need a separate personal auto policy simply because they are driving someone else’s insured vehicle. The vehicle must meet Virginia’s insurance or financial responsibility requirements, and the borrower must be legally authorized to drive. If the borrower has a personal auto policy, it can provide additional coverage for a non-owned vehicle, depending on the policy terms.

Does the owner’s insurance carrier need to be notified before you borrow the car?

Virginia’s permissive use statute does not require advance notice to the insurer as a condition of coverage for an occasional permissive borrower. However, individual policies can contain requirements for household members, regular drivers, or vehicles used on a regular basis.

Can a passenger in a borrowed car file a claim against both drivers?

Yes. An injured passenger can pursue compensation from each driver whose negligence contributed to the crash. The insurance policies that apply depend on fault, coverage terms, and the circumstances of the accident.

What if the vehicle owner has no insurance?

The borrowing driver’s own policy can provide coverage if its terms cover the accident. Uninsured motorist coverage under Virginia Code Section 38.2-2206 can also apply when no liability insurance is available. The injured person can also pursue the driver personally and, when the facts support it, the owner through a negligent entrustment claim.

How much does it cost to hire a Roanoke car accident attorney for a borrowed car claim?

Fishwick & Associates PLC handles personal injury claims on a contingency fee basis, so you owe no attorney fees unless the firm recovers compensation for you. The initial consultation is free, and the fee percentage and case costs are explained before you sign an agreement.

Do Roanoke police reports affect an injury claim?

A police crash report can provide useful information about the accident, including witness details, insurance information, and the responding officer’s initial observations. Under Virginia Code Section 46.2-379, the report itself cannot be used as evidence at a trial arising from the accident, so other evidence such as witness testimony, photographs, vehicle data, and admissible medical evidence becomes important.

How long do you have to file a personal injury lawsuit after a borrowed car accident in Virginia?

Virginia Code Section 8.01-243(A) sets a two-year deadline for filing most personal injury lawsuits, measured from the date of the injury. Different deadlines or rules can apply in certain circumstances, including cases involving minors or government entities, so the applicable deadline should be confirmed as early as possible.

Get a Straight Answer About Your Case

Clear Guidance From A Team That Knows How To Win

SHARE POST ON:

Related Articles

After a hit-and-run e-bike crash in Virginia, compensation can come from uninsured motorist coverage under an auto policy covering you or an eligible household member. Medical payments coverage and health insurance may also help with...

After an e-bike accident in Virginia, call 911, seek medical care, document the scene, and preserve the bicycle before speaking with insurance adjusters. An injured rider may seek compensation through the driver’s liability insurance or...

After a car accident, you may expect your insurance coverage to help with the costs of your injuries and other losses. But when an insurance company denies coverage, you may be left wondering how to...

Call Now Button