What Is an Original Source Under the False Claims Act?

The False Claims Act is one of the legal system’s most important tools for combating fraud involving public funds. But the law does not rely on the government alone to uncover wrongdoing. Through what are known as qui tam actions, private citizens can bring False Claims Act lawsuits on behalf of the United States when they have information about fraud against the government.

These private citizens, known as “relators,” can receive a portion of the government’s recovery if the action is successful. That potential financial recovery creates a powerful incentive for people with knowledge of fraud to come forward.

But there is a catch. A relator cannot simply take allegations that are already public, package them into a lawsuit, and claim a share of the government’s recovery. When substantially the same allegations have already been publicly disclosed through certain sources, the False Claims Act generally requires something more: the relator must qualify as an “original source.”

The False Claims Act’s Public Disclosure Bar

One feature of the False Claims Act, commonly called the False Claims Act’s “public disclosure bar,” is codified at 31 U.S.C. § 3730(e)(4)(A).

Under the public disclosure bar, a court must dismiss an action when substantially the same allegations or transactions were publicly disclosed in certain federal criminal, civil, or administrative proceedings in which the government or its agent is a party; in a congressional, Government Accountability Office, or other federal report, hearing, audit, or investigation; or through the news media. 

However, there are two important exceptions. First, the public disclosure bar does not require dismissal when the Government opposes it. In other words, if the Government wants to give a relator a share despite the relator’s allegations being publicly known, the Government has that option. The Government, however, is not likely to exercise that option because having to provide a share of the recovery to a relator limits what the Government earns. 

Second, the public disclosure bar does not apply when the person bringing the action qualifies as an “original source.” This is particularly important for whistleblowers because information about potential fraud does not necessarily become useless merely because some aspects of the fraud have become public. A person with genuine inside knowledge may still possess information that the government and the public do not know.

Who Qualifies as an Original Source?

Congress defines “original source” in the False Claims Act and 31 U.S.C. § 3730(e)(4)(B) in particular. There are two ways to qualify.

First, a person may be an original source if, before the public disclosure occurred, the person voluntarily disclosed to the Government the information on which the allegations or transactions in the claim are based.

Second, a person may qualify if he or she possesses knowledge that is both “independent of” and “materially adds to” the publicly disclosed allegations or transactions and voluntarily provides that information to the Government before filing the False Claims Act action.

This distinction can make a significant difference. Suppose the news media reports allegations that a government contractor has been improperly billing a federal agency. An employee who merely reads the same news reports and files a lawsuit based on them may encounter the public disclosure bar. But an employee with independent knowledge that materially adds to what has already been reported may still qualify as an original source.

The important question is therefore not simply whether something about the alleged fraud has previously become public. The relationship between the public disclosure and the relator’s own information matters.

The Rule in Virginia and the Fourth Circuit

The law governing the public disclosure bar changed significantly in 2010.

Before the amendment, § 3730(e)(4) expressly stated that courts lacked jurisdiction over certain actions based upon publicly disclosed allegations. The Supreme Court accordingly described the old version as a “jurisdiction-removing provision.” Rockwell International Corp. v. United States, 549 U.S. 457, 468–69 (2007).

Congress subsequently changed that language. The current version no longer states that courts lack jurisdiction. Instead, it instructs courts to dismiss qualifying actions unless the Government opposes dismissal.

The United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit—which includes Virginia—recognized this distinction in United States ex rel. Radcliffe v. Purdue Pharma L.P., 737 F.3d 908 (4th Cir. 2013). The Fourth Circuit explained that, while the former public disclosure bar operated as a jurisdictional limitation, the amended version does not. Id. at 916.

That difference is more than semantic. Under the current statute, the public disclosure rule is not treated as a limitation on the federal court’s basic subject-matter jurisdiction over the case. And because the statute expressly provides an exception when dismissal is opposed by the Government, the Government retains an important role when the public disclosure bar is raised.

What If the Relator Never Saw the Public Disclosure?

A potential relator should also understand that ignorance of an earlier public disclosure does not necessarily solve the problem.

In Radcliffe, the Fourth Circuit explained that the public disclosure analysis “focuses on the similarity of the allegations of fraud rather than the derivation of the knowledge of fraud.” 737 F.3d at 917.

In other words, the question is not necessarily whether the relator copied the public disclosure—or even knew it existed. If substantially the same allegations or transactions were already publicly disclosed through one of the sources identified by the statute, the public disclosure bar may still apply.

That makes the “original source” requirement especially important. A whistleblower considering a False Claims Act action should determine not only what he or she knows, but also what has already been publicly disclosed and, if there has been a disclosure, whether the whistleblower possesses independent information that materially adds to it.

The False Claims Act rewards private citizens who provide valuable assistance in uncovering fraud against the government. But Congress drew a line between whistleblowers who contribute meaningful information and lawsuits based merely on allegations already in the public domain. Determining which side of that line a potential relator falls on can be critical to whether a False Claims Act case may proceed.

Do You Have Knowledge of Fraud Against the Government? Contact the Qui Tam Attorneys at Fishwick & Associates to Discuss Your Options

False Claims Act cases involve complicated procedural and substantive requirements, and the public disclosure bar can present an important issue before a case ever reaches its merits. Potential whistleblowers should therefore consider speaking with an attorney before filing a qui tam action or disclosing information that may relate to fraud against the government.

If you believe you have information concerning false claims, government contractor fraud, health care fraud, or another scheme involving government funds, contact Fishwick & Associates PLC to discuss your situation and your potential rights under the False Claims Act.

References

False Claims Act, 31 U.S.C. § 3701, et seq.

Rockwell International Corp. v. United States, 549 U.S. 457 (2007).

United States ex rel. Radcliffe v. Purdue Pharma L.P., 737 F.3d 908 (4th Cir. 2013).

Get a Straight Answer About Your Case

Clear Guidance From A Team That Knows How To Win

SHARE POST ON:

Related Articles

After a hit-and-run e-bike crash in Virginia, compensation can come from uninsured motorist coverage under an auto policy covering you or an eligible household member. Medical payments coverage and health insurance may also help with...

After an e-bike accident in Virginia, call 911, seek medical care, document the scene, and preserve the bicycle before speaking with insurance adjusters. An injured rider may seek compensation through the driver’s liability insurance or...

After a car accident, you may expect your insurance coverage to help with the costs of your injuries and other losses. But when an insurance company denies coverage, you may be left wondering how to...

Call Now Button